We haven't had a proper Dancing With the Stars Season 18 elimination since that shocking double elimination in Week 2. Week 3 Billy Dee Williams had to drop out due to injury, and no one was eliminated on Week 4 because of the Switch Up. However, the reprise is over, and Cody Simpson and partner Witney Carson paid the price. Wow!

After their Week 3 and Week 4 scores and votes were combined, Cody and Witney were found lacking. We gotta say, we thought his fans were going to carry him further. But hey, at least they got to dance their Disney Week Samba, which earned them 34 out of 40 points. It was good!

Cody said the Dancing With the Stars experience was an "amazing." About going home, he said, "It is what it is." Witney said she's sad. She feels like people didn't get to really see Cody yet. She loved being a pro for her first season. In the video package Cody said the show has affected his life in a very positive way.

Did the right couple go home? Who do you think will be eliminated next week? Let us know in the comments below!

Dancing With the Stars airs on Mondays at 8 p.m. ET/PT on ABC.