The Dancing With the Stars Season 18 semifinals ended with a shocking twist: Charlie White and Sharna Burgess were sent packing. Many thought the ice dancer and his fan-fave pro were strong contenders for the Mirror Ball, so to see them leave before the finals was gut wrenching.

We're not going to lie: We're definitely upset. Yes, the final four are all great, and it's hard to say exactly who we would have offed instead of Charlie, but as far as we're concerned he shouldn't have gone anywhere this week. He's one of the strongest dancers this year, his upbeat attitude is utterly heartwarming, and his partnership with Sharna has been fantastic. Plus, don't you want to know what tricks Sharna had up her sleeve for the Freestyle? We're confident it would have been a dance to remember.

However, America fell through. Is it because most voters didn't agree with us? Did Charlie's fans get complacent after his high scores last week? Maybe people who love both Charlie and his ice dancing partner Meryl Davis threw their votes her way because she was at the bottom of the leaderboard?

Whatever the case, what's done is done. And we want to know: Are you upset to see Charlie go, or did you think it was his time? Was this season just so competitive that anyone could have been out this week?

Vote in our reaction buttons, and sound off in the comments below!