For once, the men of Dancing With the Stars were wearing more makeup than the women. A lot more. And we don’t just mean the guys in KISS.

DWTS Season 14, Week 4 is Rock Week and apparently there was an unofficial rule that the men had to wear guyliner for tonight’s Performance Show. Almost all of them got Jack Sparrow-meets-Adam Lambert with their eyes, even though guyliner has a history of tripping folks up almost as often as capes, long dresses (sorry, Maks!) and that dang smoke machine.

Back on Season 11’s Rock Week, Derek Hough blamed a wardrobe malfunction on the poor performance he and Jennifer Grey turned in. "This is what happened tonight," Derek told E! after the show. "The dance was going well, I told [Jennifer] to get fierce, and she was all in it. And then at the end, this eyeliner got in my eye! Then I flew off and she was off balance and it was a mess. So basically, the moral of the story is don't wear eyeliner if you're a guy."

Oh well! Everyone blew off that advice. Did you like the results?

Watch the next Dancing With the Stars results show on Tuesday, April 10 at 8 p.m. ET/PT on ABC.