Credit: GSN Photo: GSN Promotional DWTS Photo

Cheryl Burke recently teased fans with the idea of a Dancing With the Stars All-Stars season coming as soon as two seasons from now. Who knows if that will really pan out, but it already has us planning a dream cast — even if it means pairing celebs with new pros because, for example, Erin Andrews and Mel B can’t both dance with pro Maksim Chmerkovskiy. It could be fun to see that dynamic too. Jealousy? Better results?

Here are some of our dream cast names from every season. (We stuck with non-winners to give them a chance for redemption and glory.) This is way more than ABC needs, but you never know who might be busy or too afraid to step back into the ring. Besides, there will be a whole new crop of potential All-Stars coming in Season 14.

Vote for your favorite suggestions and add your own picks in the comments.

Who would you want to see for DWTS All-Stars? Weigh in on our Facebook page.