Darryl Strawberry, 49
Darryl could use DWTS’ classic PR redemption treatment. He was a baseball icon in the 1980s and '90s, often as remembered for his controversial actions as his athletic prowess. He's a changed man now, but he’s not above doing reality TV — he was on The Celebrity Apprentice in 2010 but was fired after three episodes. He seems up for a challenge and a tough DWTS experience with, say, Cheryl Burke or Karina Smirnoff, could be a good platform for the next chapter in his life.