There’s no shortage of hotties with naughty bodies when it comes to Glee’s bodacious cast. Between the enviable coifs, the bedroom eyes, and dancers physiques, it’s obvious that some real genetic gifts have come into our lives, one choreographed number at a time. So, when Maxim rolled out its Hot 100 for 2013, we weren’t surprised to see two Glee gals make the cut: Lea Michele (Rachel Berry) and Naya Rivera (Santana Lopez).

The list includes models, actresses, and icons galore, and so it was quite an honor that both ladies made it into the top 50. Lea came in at number 39, behind Amanda Seyfried and Zoe Saldana, while Naya landed at 45, right behind Modern Family’s Sarah Hyland.

And while we’re thrilled that the world recognizes how gorgeous these gals are, we have to ask: did they get it right? Both Naya and Lea are beautiful, sexy girls, and both show off their assets on Glee. But over the years, we’ve come to see Naya’s Santana as the sex kitten of the pair: With her dirty dancing skills, sassy attitude, and short hemlines, how can you look anywhere else?

Prior to Season 4, Rachel was all buttoned up in knee-highs, mock turtlenecks, and printed sweaters. But thanks to Sarah Jessica Parker, she’s been looking fine all season. So, here’s the question: Is Lea really hotter than Naya, or did Maxim get things backwards?

Source: Maxim