Glee Season 5, Episode 3: “The Quarterback” — an emotional tribute to Cory Monteith (Finn), who passed away suddenly this July — is less than a week away. The Cory Montieth tribute airs on October 10, but unlike previous episodes, where song lists are released weeks in advance, information about the music for this episode is being kept under wraps.

So far, we have only a rumored tracklist with five possible songs. If the online chatter is true, Santana (Naya Rivera) will sing The Band Perry’s “If I Die Young,” while Mercedes (Amber Riley) will sing The Pretenders’ “I’ll Stand By You.”

The New Directions are rumored to be singing “Seasons of Love” from RENT, and James Taylor’s “Fire and Rain” is also rumored to be in the episode, though we’re not yet sure who’s singing it. Lastly, Rachel (Lea Michele) will perform a song, which some have speculated will be Bob Dylan’s “To Make You Feel My Love.’

Even if this reported song list is true, we figure it still leaves a handful more songs. Glee episodes can have up to eight songs, after all. Earlier this summer, we took a poll of Glee readers, asking which songs you would like to see included in the Cory tribute.

Past Favorites

Credit: Eddy Chen/©2013 Fox Broadcasting Co.

We know that Glee plans to incorporate at least one song that has previously been sung on the show. Having Mercedes sing “I’ll Stand By You,” fits the bill, but here are the top four previous hits you want to see.

“Without You,” by David Guetta feat. Usher 15%

This song comes from Season 3, Episode 10: “Yes/No.” Finn is feeling lost and alone in the world; empty of any purpose or worth. Rachel sings this song to let him know that she can’t imagine her life without him. Later in the episode, he gets down on one knee and asks her to be his wife.

“Don’t Stop Believing” by Journey 14%

Sung both in the pilot and during Rachel’s Season 4 Broadway audition, Journey’s “Don’t Stop Believin’” is forever intertwined in the DNA of Glee itself. It would be a fitting choice for this episode.

“Faithfully” by Journey 12%

An legendary Finn and Rachel duet from Glee’s Season 1 finale. The first time Finn told Rachel he loved her was right before they went onstage to sing it. To have Rachel sing this song solo would be both poignant and heartbreaking. “I'm forever yours. Faithfully.”

“Can’t Fight This Feeling” by REO Speedwagon 10%

It’s the song Finn sings in the shower when Mr. Schue (Matthew Morrison) overhears him in the locker room and first begins to understand what amazing potential the football star has as an artist. In the tribute episode, we’d love to see the entire New Directions perform this song in Finn’s honor — with flashback clips of that now-famous shower scene spliced in.

New Selections

Credit: Adam Rose/FOX ©2012 Fox Broadcasting Co.

In addition, we took another poll asking which new songs you hoped Glee would choose to cover in the episode.

“My Heart Will Go On” by Celine Dion, sung by Lea Michele 26%

Perhaps the most famous love song of our time; a heartbreaking tale of love and loss. If Lea sang this song, there wouldn’t be a dry eye in the house.

“Hallelujah” by Jeff Buckley 13%

This sweet, mournful Jeff Buckley tune was a favorite of Glee fans on our Facebook page. “Your faith was strong but you needed proof / You saw her bathing on the roof / Her beauty and the moonlight overthrew you.”

“Just a Dream” by Carrie Underwood 12%

It’s the heartbreaking song about a young girl whose husband-to-be dies right before their wedding day. Considering Finn and Rachel’s romantic history, the words ring particularly true. “Baby why'd you leave me / Why'd you have to go? / I was counting on forever, now I'll never know.”

“You’ll Be In My Heart” by Phil Collins 11%

There’s something about this Phil Collins classic — and beloved Disney hit — that summarizes all our feelings on Cory’s passing just perfectly.

“'Cause you'll be in my heart / Yes, you'll be in my heart / I'll be there from this day on, now and forever more.”


Beth Douglass is an Associate Editor at Wetpaint Entertainment. She's our resident Glee expert and loves celebrity kids. Follow her on Twitter and Google+!