Credit: FOX © 2014 FOX Broadcasting Co. Photo: Blaine and Kurt in Glee Season 5, Episode 14: “New New York”

Glee Season 5, Episode 14: “New New York” marked the first full hour the Fox show was set solely in the Big Apple, and although new New Yorkers Blaine (Darren Criss), Artie (Kevin McHale), and Sam (Chord Overstreet) each had trouble adjusting to big city life, they sang their way through the tough times with tunes like “Downtown” and “Don’t Sleep in the Subway.”

The hour concluded with a surprise appearance by Mercedes (Amber Riley), who has temporarily relocated to the east coast. And although Mercedes didn’t get sing any songs this week, we know she’ll be back for next Tuesday’s Episode 15: “Bash.”

Watch all of the performances from Season 5, Episode 14: “New New York” below and pick your fave!