Credit: Tyler Golden/FOX ©2014 Fox Broadcasting Co. Photo: Kurt Watches From the Wings in Glee Season 5, Episode 17: “Opening Night”

Despite some intense fear and worry that she wouldn’t be able to deliver Rachel‘s (Lea Michele) inaugural performance of Funny Girl more or less went off without a hitch. Sure, Sue (Jane Lynch) leaving at intermission didn’t look great to the New York Times critic, but Rachel channeled her love for Finn (Cory Monteith) into a tear-jerking rendition of “Who Are You Now?” in the second act — and boy did it pay off. Broadway has a new baby and her name is Rachel Berry!

Watch all of Rachel’s Funny Girl performances from Season 5, Episode 17: “Opening Night” below, as well as her take on a few pop hits, and let us know which performance was your fave!