Credit: Frazer Harrison/Getty Images, Fernando Lucena/Startraks Photo: Ashley Benson and Darren Criss

Ashley Benson is the sassy but kind-hearted Queen Bee Hanna on Pretty Little Liars. Darren Criss plays Kurt’s crush on Glee. But before these two gained fame on their respective shows, they were totally an item!

Well, sort of.

Ashley and Darren played high school friends — and later, love interests — on ABC's Eastwick, a now-canceled drama about modern day witches that premiered in 2009.

Ashley's character, Mia, was the spunky daughter of Rebecca Romijn's Roxie, while Darren played Josh, the cute but nerdy little brother of Matt Dallas's Chad.

Credit: YouTube Photo: Darren Criss and Ashley Benson in ABC's Eastwick

Popular Ashley and an adorable nerd boy — is anyone else sensing a precursor to PLL's Hanna and Lucas? If you're still upset about Hanna's new guy on PLL, who is totally not Lucas, maybe these clips of Mia and Josh's sweet relationship can help fill that void.

Oh, and P.S., we're totally loving Darren with his longer, curly hairstyle. Blaine's clean-cut look is superhot, too, but we dig this laid-back surfer vibe.