While Sue Sylvester may love to make fun of Will Schuester’s style (and hair!), we happen to think he dresses just fine, which is why we’re seriously considering dressing up as the Spanish teacher turned New Directions leader this Halloween. With a few boyish pieces and Will’s ubiquitous vest, all we need is a heavy duty bottle of hair gel to make this look authentic. (And no, we will not be rapping.)

Get Will’s spiffy duds for Halloween:

Start with the all-important button down... Merona Button Up Shirt, $19.99; ... And make it distinctly Mr. Shue by adding a tweed vest. Signature Luxe Washable Tweed Tunic Vest, $49; Snag a striped tie that’s good for everyday wear and give it to your favorite guy after Halloween. Jos. A. Bank Executive Double Stripe Tie, $59.50; Tuck your tails into these comfy chinos in a straight fit. Lucky Brand Civilian Skinny Boyfriend Chino Pant, $79.50; A solid brogue is a great shoe choice, in or out of costume. ASOS Martin Tweed Lace Up Shoe, $53.92; Keep everything neat with a sturdy brown belt. BDG Classic Skinny Leather Belt, $28