We’re beyond thrilled to have Quinn (Dianna Agron) finally back at McKinley on Glee this week. What we’re not so thrilled about is that she’s dating some married professor who doesn’t exactly sound like a winner. So we thought we’d offer our suggestions for the five guys who would be a much better fit for her. You’re welcome, Quinn!

5. Brody Weston

We’re not really feeling Brody (Dean Geyer) for Rachel (Lea Michele), but Quinn actually seems like a good match for this hunky bad boy. Plus, he’ll be sure not to try anything with Cassandra while he’s dating Quinn, since we now know what a genius slapper Quinn is. Still, we’d hate to see Q jeopardize her friendship with Rachel over a guy. We’d hope by now they’d subscribe to the “sisters before misters” school of thought.

4. Noah Puckerman

Credit: Mike Yarish/FOX ©2011 Fox Broadcasting Co.

Call us sentimentalists, but there’s something about knowing that Quinn and Puck (Mark Salling) have that adorable baby girl together that makes us wonder if they might give things one more chance. Now that Puck seems to have mellowed, while Quinn is making less-than-admirable dating choices, we have our fingers crossed that they rekindle things.

3. Finn Hudson

Saying that these two have had their ups and downs would be an understatement. And sure, we love Finchel as much as the next person but he and Rachel clearly need some time apart. That’s why we think that Quinn could help Finn (Cory Monteith) continue to get out of his Lima comfort zone, while Finn could help Quinn become a little more responsible. Let’s just hope they stay out of hot tubs.

2. Hunter Clarington

We don’t know much about this new Warbler captain yet, but we do know that he likes white cats and that he’s smokin’ hot. Somehow, these two seem like a perfect match to us. Or maybe we just want a way to ensure that the Warblers continue to perform on the show as much as possible.

1. Sam Evans

There’s definitely something brewing between Brittany (Heather Morris) and Sam (Chord Overstreet), but are they really the best fit? Sam and Brittany might almost be too similar, and we love Brittany with Santana (obvi), so maybe it’s finally time for Fabrevans to give things one more try. Sam is no longer as naive and timid as he was when they first dated, meaning the time might be right for Version 2.0.