Brody (Dean Geyer) may have hooked up with Cassie (Kate Hudson) and liked it, we might add — but he and Rachel (Lea Michele) have shared a certain chemistry of their own since they first met.

When Rachel kissed Brody in Season 4, Episode 9: “Swan Song,” we had a feeling things were about to heat up between the two, and now it appears our hunches may be right.

On December 7, Glee creator Ryan Murphy tweeted this photo of Brody getting up close and personal in an NYC apartment with a girl who appears to be Rachel. But it’s his caption for the photo that’s kind of throwing us off. “Guess who?” is all that Ryan wrote.

With those bangs and that outfit, the girl in the photo certainly looks like Rachel. If only her head wasn’t turned so far away from the camera. We’d like to be able to know for sure.

Credit: Instagram

One thing worth noting: The girl in the photo is wearing blue, and we've barely seen Rachel wear a single speck of color since her big makeover in Episode 3. For the most part. her outfits have been all-black, all the time, with neutral accents occasionally mixed in.

If the girl in the blue dress isn’t Rachel, who is she? Our best guess would be her new ballet dancer rival, Alexandra. Rachel did steal Alexandra’s crown at the Winter Showcase this year. Could it be that Alexandra is up for a little revenge?

Source: Ryan Murphy on Twitter

Can’t get enough Gleetastic goodness? Like us on Facebook or follow us on Twitter!