Credit: Adam Rose/FOX ©2012 Fox Broadcasting Co.

Marley (Melissa Benoist) was thisclose to doing it with Jake (Jacob Artist) in Glee Season 4, Episode 14: “I Do,”  when she decided against it. And even though they didn’t go through with the hotel room hustle, they left the possibility open for future, um, interactions.

So, you can imagine our surprise when Marley told Ryder (Blake Jenner) that someday he would find the girl for him, and instead of thanking her, he kissed her — in the McKinley hallway!

Whoa. Considering Ryder and Jake supposedly got over their bro-fight for Marley’s heart with both parties cool with the arrangement, this is a huge surprise.

We have so many questions, we don’t even know where to start. Will Marley tell Jake? Will Ryder? What will happen to Jarley? Will Jake ever forgive Ryder? Will Marley leave Jake for Ryder, knowing that he still really likes her? So. Many. Questions. We’re dying to know what you think.