Credit: Michael Buckner/Getty Images/us.ASOS.com Photo: Lea Michele Wears an ASOS Lace Shirt as a Dress at the American Horror Story Premiere

Lea Michele (Rachel) showed up to the premiere of American Horror Story in a gorgeous lace navy minidress. Or so we thought. As it turns out, Lea’s lacy navy attire is actually nothing but a top!

Lea sported an elegant lace high-neck cut out top by ASOS for her red carpet attire. It’s a gorgeous design that hugs every part of her petite figure — but should Lea have worn something else along with it?

The ASOS model paired her top with tight black leggings, while Lea opted for a sans-pants look that really shows of her toned gams.

And while not everyone can pull off a top-only style, Lea is petite enough that her shirt didn’t ride up as far as it would on, say, Blake Lively. But was Lea’s shorter stature enough to save her from a fashion faux pas? It’s time for you to sound off!