Lea Michele vs. Demi Lovato: Who Sang “Give Your Heart a Break” Better?

Rachel (Lea Michele) and Brody (Dean Geyer) sang a beautiful version of “Give Your Heart a Break” in Glee’s “The Break-Up.” Although Rachel had originally asked her boyfriend Finn (Cory Monteith) to sing the romantic duet with her, we were pretty impressed by how Brochel sounded.

Demi Lovato’s video shows the emotional side of the popstar, who sings about the evolution of her relationship within the song.

On Glee, the duo performed the song with a thoroughly romantic bent on the stage at Callbacks.

Which version do you think is better — Demi’s story-telling video or the heartfelt harmony-heavy one sung by Lea and Dean?

Can’t get enough Gleetastic goodness? Like us on Facebook or follow us on Twitter!