Form-fitting. Black. Sexy.

Both Lea Michele (Rachel) and Naya Rivera (Santana) definitely had those words in mind as they chose their outfits for the American Horror Story: Asylum premiere on October 13. The Glee stars both went for tight black when it comes to their evening looks, though Naya mixed things up by adding a pop of color, while Lea stuck to her usual plunging necklines and cleavage-baring couture.

Lea hit the red carpet in a slinky black Armani dress, Rene Cavallinaheels, a Fendi bag, and jewelry by Samira 13. And yes, as usual, the Glee starlet showed off plenty of skin. Naya, on the other hand, paired her tight leather skirt with a not-as-racy red turtleneck. It’s colorful, eye-catching and bright — but not nearly as overtly sexy as Lea’s attire.

Which actress do you think nailed her fright night look the best?

Can’t get enough Gleetastic goodness? Like us on Facebook or follow us on Twitter!