Credit: Getty Images

Naya Rivera (Santana Lopez) sang a rendition of the Taylor Swift song “Mine” to Brittany (Heather Morris) on Glee Season 4, Episode 4 “The Break-Up.” It was an emotional episode all around, and this was one of the most heart-wrenching covers performed.

In the original version of the song, Taylor Swift celebrates the strength of her relationship by singing the song to a boy who has stuck with her even when she “ran out crying.” There are pictures hung whimsically outside, silhouettes and kissing, and a happy resolution.

In the Glee version, the song didn’t end quite so pleasantly. After Santana finished singing the song to a tearful Brittany, she broke up with her. When the song ended, Brittany wasn’t the only one crying — we were feeling a little moist in the eyes too.

So, who sang the song better — Did Naya’s Santana cast it in a new light that made you love it even more than the original? Was Taylor’s version more true to the lyrics? You be the judge.

Can’t get enough Gleetastic goodness? Like us on Facebook or follow us on Twitter!

Credit: YouTube Photo: Watch Santana Sing Taylor Swift's "Mine" to Brittany in Glee Season 4, Episode 4: “The Break-Up” (VIDEO)
Credit: TaylorSwiftVEVO on YouTube Photo: Official Music Video for Taylor Swift's "Mine"