Ryan Murphy, you’re such a tease! The Glee creator tweeted a pic of Rachel (Lea Michele) and Brody (Dean Geyer) looking less than thrilled on the NYADA stage. The caption? “Creep drama.” What could he mean by that?

Well, Ryan may in fact be referring to the song “Creep,” which would mean that Glee is finally doing a song by Radiohead. Sure, there are other songs called “Creep,” — one by TLC, and another by Stone Temple Pilots — but we don’t really think either of those versions make sense within the context of Rachel and Brody’s relationship.

If you think we’re just swallowing crazy pills with this prediction, consider the first line of the 90s hit: “When you were here before, couldn’t look you in the eye...” Well, these two couldn’t be avoiding each other’s gaze more than they are in this photo!

Plus, Rachel and Brody each seem to have their own shocking secret that is probably eating away at them: Rachel slept with Finn and is (apparently) pregnant, while Brody seems to be doing a little paid sex work on the side. We think a song with lyrics as self-loathing as these, the song doesn’t seem at all out of place for these two:

I want you to notice

 When I'm not around

You're so very special

I wish I was special

 

But I’m a creep

I’m a weirdo

What the hell am I doing here?

I don’t belong here

 

We could be totally wrong here, of course. Maybe Ryan just means that Rachel and Brody are both creeps? Frankly, we can’t really argue that point. These two have both been really dishonest with each other, and we’re pretty sure Santana is about to uncover the uncomfortable truths they’ve been hiding.

What do you think. Does our theory hold water?

UPDATE: We love being right! Ryan Murphy confirmed this Glee song spoiler to TV Line during the February 27 PaleyFest Icon Award presentation.

“I’ve always wanted to do that Radiohead song, ‘Creep,’” Murphy told TV Line reporters. "And [Radiohead] has been really lovely, saying that when we had [an appropriate] story, we’d talk about it.”

This explains why Lea Michele had such an “intense and “exhausting” day on set earlier this week! “Lea had to sing ['Creep'] — which is a hard song — for half a day. It’s very operatic.” We absolutely can’t wait to hear it!

Source: Ryan Murphy’s Twitter, TV Line