Back in 2009, when Darren Criss (Blaine) was just getting his start in Hollywood, the Glee star landed a role on ABC’s Eastwick, an hour long show about modern-day witches living in smalltown America.

Do you know who played his character’s love interest on this quirky one-season-only drama? None other than Pretty Little Liars star Ashley Benson.

That’s right, before Hanna Marin ever met her sexy BF Caleb, the fashion-forward blond was swapping spit with Blaine from Glee! Ashley and Darren both spent the weekend at the Toronto International Film Festival. His new Kristen Wiig movie, Imogene, premiered at the festival, and so did her racy new Selena Gomez flick, Spring Breakers.

Darren and Ashley met up at a Spring Breakers after party on September 7, and a photographer snapped a cute photo of former co-stars mid-hug.

Ashley’s also recently been spotted hanging out with Glee’s Chord Overstreet (Sam), but don’t automatically assume that Ashley’s got anything romantic going on with either of them. The PLL star has been happily dating Ryan Good — Justin Bieber’s former “swagger coach” — for a while now.

Can’t get enough Gleetastic goodness? Like us on Facebook or follow us on Twitter!