Credit: Michael Yarish/FOX © 2011 Fox Broadcasting Co. Photo: Mercedes and Rachel From Season 2 of Glee

How awesome was “Take Me or Leave Me” in Season 2, Episode 13: “Comeback”? We loved Rachel and Mercedes’ amazing performances, and it was great to see that the competition brought them closer together. The only thing this Diva-Off was missing? A winner!

We appreciate that both characters ended up feeling on top, but every good contest needs a winner — whether it’s the Oscars or the Fourth of July hot dog-eating competition. But we definitely wouldn’t want to have to choose between the two singers, at their fabulous bests. So we’ll leave that up to you!

This is it, Gleeks. Would you have awarded the victory to Mercedes (channeling Rent character Joanne) or Rachel (taking on the part of Maureen, originally played on Broadway by Glee’s own Idina Menzel!)?

And how great was the look on Sue’s face during this song? (Clearly, the words “friendly competition” have never entered her vocabulary!)