Credit: Splash News/Stephen Lovekin/Getty Images/Rabbani and Solimene Photography/Getty Images for Calvin Klein

It’s pretty hard to make Darren Criss (Blaine) look bad. The man can wear a yellow cape, green tights, and freaking cat ears — and we still think he’s just about the most attractive superhero we’ve ever seen in our entire lives. (Sorry, Joseph Gordon-Levitt. You were a close second. We promise.)

So since Darren obviously beats Lea Michele (Rachel) in a cat ears face-off — check the results if you don’t believe us — and since he also recently beat out Olympic swimmer Ryan Lochte in our sexy blue suit face-off, the only person we can think to set him against this time is... Darren himself.

That’s right. Now who’s going to win? You can’t simultaneously choose all three Darrens at once. (Unless two of the Darrens were actually just Sango Tajima in a wig, but we digress. And only like three people are going to understand our Very Potter Sequel references.)

Where were we? Right. In the photo above, Darren’s wearing three different shades of gray. Now it’s your job to figure out which shade of gray he looks best in. Vote away!

Can’t get enough Gleetastic goodness? Like us on Facebook or follow us on Twitter!