Cory Monteith, Kate Mara, and Harry Shum Jr at the American Horror Story Premiere in Los Angeles on October 3, 2011
In American Horror Story, Kate Mara plays Hayden, a young girl facing the consequences of an affair with her teacher (Dylan McDermott). So are we jealous that she gets to kiss Dylan McDermott? Yeah, a little. But we’re even more jealous to see her chillin’ on the red carpet with Glee cuties Cory Monteith (Finn) and Harry Shum Jr. (Mike)!