Credit: PPNY/GSNY/Splash News Photo: Penn Badgley Tales a Break From Playing Softball for a Gossip Girl Episode in Brooklyn on July 19, 2011

Blake Lively is a hard act to follow, but X-Men: First Class star Zoe Kravitz, current hipster It-girl and daughter of rocker Lenny Kravitz, would totally be up to the challenge. According to the New York Post, the gorgeous starlet was spotted getting into a cab with Gossip Girl's Penn Bagdley (Dan Humphrey) after a Friends With Benefits party — at 1:30AM! Has Penn moved on from his break up with Blake?

According to Penn's rep, "[Penn and Zoe] just shared a cab," and last we heard Zoe was dating X-Men hottie Michael Fassbender. But still, 1:30 a.m. is a little late for a casual cab ride. Just saying. Is there more to this story than meets the eye?

Source: New York Post