Credit: Justin Steffman/Splash News Photo: Penn Badgley at a Gossip Girl Fight Scene in New York City on July 14, 2011

Looks like Gossip Girl star Penn Badgley is recovering just fine after breaking up with his oft-naked co-star, Blake Lively. For the second time this week, the New York Post is reporting that Penn and Zoe have been spending time together — even though, last we heard, Kravitz was dating X-Men hottie Michael Fassbender.  

After oh-so-scandalously sharing a cab following the Friends with Benefits  premiere party, Penn and Zoe were caught catching the latest Jennifer Aniston flick, Horrible Bosses, in Union Square. Sources say that Penn had his arm around Zoe while they waited in line for tickets.

However, things got awkward for Penn when Aniston’s character said, “Did you see Gossip Girl last night? I [bleeped] myself so hard [watching] that Penn Badgley guy, I broke a nail.” According to the Post, the look on Penn’s face was “priceless”, and the peeved pair promptly walked out of the movie!

Source: New York Post