Credit: The CW

We’re the first to admit it: We are so obsessed with The Carrie Diaries, it’s kind of pathetic. There’s just something about the characters that makes us constantly surprised and delighted and hungry for more. And what better way to spice up our favorite show, than with our favorite holiday: Halloween.

In Season 1, Episode 4, Carrie (AnnaSophia Robb) and Sebastian (Austin Butler) make plans to be apart on the big day (it’s cool, guys, it’s not like it’s Valentine’s Day or whatever). While two parties are usually better than one, both have their hitches. Here’s what happens:

When Carrie is invited to a Halloween party in the city by Larissa (Freema Agyman), she decides to invite Walt (Brenden Dooling) to go with her to keep her company. It doesn’t take long before the night goes awry and Carrie is forced to babysit Larissa, who has clearly taken too many drugs. Walt finds himself in an uncomfortable position after a party guest gets a little too close for comfort. Elsewhere, Maggie (Katie Findlay) convinces Mouse (Ellen Wong) to go with her to Sebastian’s Halloween party at the diner to help keep tabs on him. After Doritt’s (Stefania Owen) attempt to sneak out of the house is thwarted, she discovers hanging out with her father (Matt Letscher) isn’t so bad.

Source: The CW