We love ladies in red — especially when they’re red hot. And there’s no arguing that Mad Men’s Christina Hendricks is one of the most gorgeous women in Hollywood. She looked particularly fierce in a red CH Carolina Herrera frock at the opening of the House of Walker on November 30, 2010.

full size Who Wore It Best: Lily van der Woodsen vs. Christina Hendricks in Carolina Herrera
Credit: Giovanni Rufino/The CW ©2010 The CW Network; Dario Cantatore/Getty Images

But then we spotted Lily van der Woodsen (Kelly Rutherford) sporting that very dress in Gossip Girl’s Season 4, Episode 16, “While You Weren’t Sleeping.” The always impeccable Lily looked flawless with her subtle Loub pumps and chic, up-swept ‘do.

Question is: Who wore the Carolina Herrera number better? The prim Lil? Or the sultry, sexy Christina?

Want more Gossip Girl goodness? “Like” us on Facebook! You know you love us. XOXO

Still craving more Gossip Girl fashion? Easy! Just go here.