Which Former It Girl Almost Played Georgina Sparks on Gossip Girl?

It’s hard to imagine an Upper East Side not terrorized by Michelle Trachtenberg’s Georgina Sparks. But guess what, Gossip Girl fans — Queen G was almost a very different version of herself. Before Buffy alum Michelle was cast, showrunners seriously considered another famous television star for the role.

Can you guess who it was? Flip through for the big reveal.