Which Gossip Girl Star Got Into a Bidding War With Usher For a $12,000 Puppy?

Dear animal lovers of the world,

No matter how much you want to buy an adorable pink leash-having puppy that looks like it may grow up to be Snuffleupagus, you can’t. Not if you’re bidding against Usher, anyway.

One lovely Gossip Girl star found that out the hard way when she attended the Second Annual Pencils of Promise Gala on October 25, 2012 and attempted to buy a cuddly, adorable, tiny, perfect puppy.

Which star was it? Click through to find out who’s sleeping alone tonight...