There probably aren’t many things that would leave the entire cast of Grey’s Anatomy stunned into silence but a particular Calzona scene in the Season 9 finale did just that.

In the most recent episode of Grey’s Anatomy, craniofacial surgeon Lauren (Hilarie Burton) puts the subtle moves on Arizona, sending Calzona fans across the internet into a fit of panic. Will Arizona cheat on Callie with Lauren?

Creator Shonda Rhimes recently told TV Line, “Straight people have their cheating moments all of the time.” (Ahem, Owen.)

“We’ve created this relationship that’s very interesting and complex, and I feel like we’re at a moment where this [temptation] feels earned,” Shonda added. “We’re doing something that feels very in keeping with what’s right for these characters.”

As it turns out, that “something” was so shocking it left the entire Grey’s cast stunned at the finale table read!

“There was a [Calzona] scene that was such a breathtaking moment that it stunned everyone into silence,” Shonda told TV Line. “It’s the culmination of a [season-long] journey for these two characters.”

We’re hoping that this “breaktaking moment” in a happy one and not a scene in which Arizona breaks her vows to Callie, especially after all Callie did to support her earlier this season. Perhaps the two will renew their vows instead?

What do you think, Grey’s fans? Are we being too optimistic, or is Calzona really in trouble?

Catch the next new episode of Grey’s Anatomy on Thursday, May 9, 2013, at 9 p.m. ET/PT on ABC.