Credit: Jason Kempin/Getty, WENN Photo: Olsen vs. Tisdale: Who Does Hobo-Chic Better?

Welcome to Ash Wednesday, our foray into the heart and mind of one of our fave ever cheerleaders, Ashley Tisdale. In these articles, we celebrate all the things that make The Tis great!

Today, we’re bringing you a poll to see who works the hobo chic look better. Is it Ashley Olsen, rocking the black trench coat, matching heels, and head wrap at an Yves Saint Laurent fragrance launch in NYC, or is it our Tis, pulling off the ruffled sundress look while on her way to Urth Caffee in Los Angeles?

You decide!