Ian Somerhalder and Nina Dobrev may have ended their relationship, but the actors are pros at appearing like a couple onscreen. In fact, the Vampire Diaries stars are so good at portraying Damon and Elena, fans are dying for them to take their chemistry to the big screen.

Now that Sons of Anarchy’s Charlie Hunnam has dropped out of Fifty Shades of Grey, Ian fans everywhere are campaigning for the blue-eyed heartthrob to replace him in the film. Though it was recently revealed that author E.L. James never even considered Ian for the role of Christian Grey, that hasn’t stop his avid fanbase from fantasizing about the possibility!

The hopes for a Vampire Diaries/Fifty Shades crossover doesn’t just stop there. After rumors started swirling that Dakota Johnson was also having second thoughts about participating in the project, there was only one actress TVD fans were hoping would take her place. Nina Dobrev, of course!

It looks like Dakota is firmly planted in the role of Anastasia Steele, so sadly, we don’t expect these dreams to become a reality. That said, one very gracious fan has pieced together a faux trailer for Fifty Shades, giving us a juicy taste of what could have been had Ian and Nina been chosen for the film.

Watch the fake trailer below and then let us know: Would you want to see Ian Somerhalder and Nina Dobrev star in Fifty Shades of Grey?