Credit: Splash News, Doug Meszler / Splash News Photo: Snooki vs. Shay Mitchell

Snooki used to get drunk for a living on Jersey Shore (pre-pregnancy, of course) while Shay Mitchell (Emily) plays a lesbian teenager on ABC Family's murder-mystery Pretty Little Liars. Okay, so maybe they're not living parallel lives. Nonetheless, wearing the exact same startling shade of electric blue calls for a little fashion battle, people!

Our guidette mama-to-be showed off a cobalt blue dress and matching heels while on a date in NYC with her fiancé Jionni LaValle last night (July 26). Shay, on the other hand, donned the same bright color, pairing her dress with metallic silver heels while visiting The Revolution in NYC in early June.

Try and look past the fact that Snooks has a bulging baby bump and an adorable guido on her arm, and let's get down to it. which of these girls looks hotter in a bright blue dress? Vote in our poll below!

Read more about Snooki’s pregnancy.

Want more Jersey Shore? Catch the next episode of Snooki & JWOWW on on Thursday, July 26 at 10 p.m. on MTV.

Follow Alissa Kombert on Twitter @AyeKayArt.

For more on Jersey Shore, Follow us on Twitter and Like us on Facebook.