Juan Pablo Galavis and Nikki Ferrell have endured a lot of public criticism since wrapping Season 18 of The Bachelor, but according to one eyewitness, they look “as much like a real, happy couple as you could expect.”

The attractive duo stepped out for Moet & Chandon’s “Tiny Tennis” event in Miami on Wednesday, March 19, where they weren’t shy about flaunting their (possible) love for one another. “They sat together on a bench at the outdoor rooftop lounge at the Viceroy Hotel,” an insider revealed to Us Weekly. “She had her hand on his leg as he texted. Actually, both of them were on their phones a lot.”

They may not have been staring deeply into each other’s eyes, but they did make sure to snap an adorable selfie at the event. “When no one was looking, there were flirtier with one another,” the eyewitness adds. “[They were] rubbing their noses together and kissing several times throughout the night. They kissed a little for the professional photographers, but really it was mostly when they were left alone.”

This behavior certainly makes sense given Juan’s comments during After the Final Rose. Though many viewers were upset by the anticlimactic ending, Juan seemed pretty adamant about keeping their relationship as private as possible.

That said, it looks like the couple could still be getting their happily-ever-after. According to recent reports, the duo are taking their commitment very seriously and have even been meeting with counselors! “I think they have marriage on their minds,” says Marriage Boot Camp’s Jim Carroll. “It wasn’t a very romantic fairytale ending, but I think what [Juan] did was very wise. He is very serious about commitment, that’s why he didn’t jump into the engagement right away.”

Do you think you Juan and Nikki have what it takes to make their relationship work?