Kourtney Kardashian didn’t want boyfriend Scott Disick to come to Miami during the filming of Kourtney & Kim Take Miami. In fact, Scott wasn’t allowed to come—until Kim called him and told him to get his butt on a plane. So now he’s there, but should Kourtney trust him?

Kourtney’s actions might seem harsh, but she has good reason to be worried that Scott will go off the rails in Miami, what with all the drinking and wall punching that’s happened in the past.

Lo and behold, Scott was a model of restraint in the season premiere! Kourtney was so pleased she even brought him a Rolls-Royce as a present.

But then, in episode two, Chapman entered the picture. Oh, Chapman. Scott’s bromance with his race car driving doppelganger already has us worried. He may not be out partying, but he did lie to Kourtney about racing cars, which she had forbidden him from doing. That’s never a good sign, and lying can be a verrrrrry slippery slope.

So what do you think, should Kourtney trust Scott? Or is she right to have him on a short leash?