Who Wore It Best? Kendall Jenner vs. Nicky Hilton vs. Selena Gomez in an Alice + Olivia Mini

We have to ask: Does every girl in Hollywood have the same stylist? Because it’s sure starting to look that way! On May 18, 2012, Kendall Jenner stepped out for the 19th Annual Race to Erase MS event in a leg-flaunting mini by Alice + Olivia. Easy flowing hair and Fendi Mary Janes were lovely additions to Kendall’s look — completing but not competing with the frock’s chain details.

But the reality star wasn’t the first to wear A+O’s festive number. Two years earlier, Nicky Hilton opted for the same tank-style dress while attending Party Millionaire in Monte Carlo, Monaco. With strappy metallic heels and a classic Chanel clutch, Nicky’s vibe was summery and fresh, perfect for a night out in the French Riviera!

But wait — not even the socialite was the first fashionista to wear this dress. Singer/actress Selena Gomez took at the stage in the same frock for a London concert in April 2010. The then 17-year-old kept her look young and fun with sleek, shiny strands, a Melinda Maria leaf necklace, and unexpected cowboy-style boots.

Personally, we’re feeling Kendall’s simple yet sophisticated spin on this dress — but ultimately, the choice is up to you! Who wore it best?

Jager Weatherby is a photo editor and fashion writer at Wetpaint Entertainment. Follow her on Twitter @JagerWeatherby.

Get your daily TV and pop-culture fix from Wetpaint Entertainment:  Like us on Facebook or Follow us on Twitter!