As if we weren't already scared enough from Ezra being "A," Ali being alive, and Ravenswood's overall creepiness, it looks like Lucy Hale (Aria) is trying to creep us out even more.

The Pretty Little Liars actress took to Instagram to post a photo of one of her old Halloween costumes. She wrote, "Terrifying throwback thurs. Halloween is near and my alter ego may be lurking in your closet."

If clowns scare you even more than PLL does, then do not scroll down, people. We cannot unsee Lucy's terrifying clown makeup! On screen, Lucy's costume choices aren’t nearly as scary. Her character Aria and the rest of the Little Liars dressed in Victorian outfits while trying to get some answers at Ravenswood’s Founders Day Celebration.

What do you think of Lucy's scary costume and makeup? Weigh in below!

Catch the Pretty Little Liars Season 4 winter premiere on Tuesday, January 7, 2013 at 8 p.m. ET on ABC Family.


Credit: Lucy Hale's Instagram Photo: Lucy Hale's Scary Halloween Costume