Pretty Little Liars star Lucy Hale caused quite a media frenzy recently when she posted a photo on Instagram of her kissing her new beau and sporting a shiny diamond ring on that finger. But before you start freaking out, we’re going to debunk this rumor right here. No, Lucy Hale isn’t engaged. After all, she only started seeing country crooner Joel Crouse in May. The relationship is so new that a lot of fans had no idea she was even dating someone!

So we put Viggle users to the test on Tuesday night during another exciting game of Viggle LIVE! to see if they knew the 411 on Lucy’s love life — and a whopping 77 percent of Vigglers answered correctly! Seeing as Lucy and Joel haven’t even confirmed their relationship yet — they’ve been keeping it on the DL — it’s pretty surprising that so many viewers knew about Lucy’s latest beau.

Meanwhile, 12 percent of Vigglers thought Lucy had rekindled her flame with actor Chris Zylka. The couple split (not-so-amicably) 2012 after more than a year of dating. Chris is now engaged to model Hanna Beth.

And then there are a fraction of our beloved Ezria shippers who blur the lines between fiction and reality. 11 percent of Viggle LIVE! users thought Lucy and her Pretty Little Liars co-star Ian Harding were dating IRL. Listen, we think Lucy and Ian are adorable together in their behind-the-scenes antics, but these two are just friends. Sorry to burst your bubble, Ezria fans!

Did you know Lucy was dating country singer Joel Crouse? Sound off in the comments! And don’t forget to play along next Tuesday using your Viggle app for a chance to download Lucy’s new album Road Between in Viggle Store. Get the FREE download below and start racking up those rewards!