Credit: Charles Sykes/Bravo © NBC Universal, Inc.

Remember back in the day when rapper Eminem couldn't stop writing songs about our girl Mariah Carey, claiming he dated the pop diva shortly after they met in 2001? To this day, Mimi has remained relatively tight-lipped about the rumors (though some believe her 2009 single "Obsessed" was a direct response to Slim's accusations), and during a segment of "Plead the Fifth" on Watch What Happens Live on December 22, she continued doing just that.

When host Andy Cohen asked Mariah to say three nice things about Eminem, she did what any self-respecting diva would do and dodged the question.

"They come in a package that you can carry wherever you go. People love them around the world, and they’re tasty. You can have peanut or the regular kind,” she quipped, obviously talking about M&Ms instead of Eminem. Good one, MC!

Andy's response? "Oh my god, I love it!"

And so do we! After all, Mariah has way more important things to worry about these days than dredging up decade-old rumors, like raising her adorable twins Moroccan Scott and Monroe, being a wonderful wife to hubby Nick Cannon, and prepping for the release of her fifteenth studio album. Oh yeah, and frolicking around in the snow in a skimpy red bikini, because why not?

Eminem has yet to respond to Mariah's subtle shade toss, which means this feud might finally be over for good. But then again, his last Mimi diss in 2009 was just a "warning" so maybe it's only the beginning…

What do you think of Mariah's response to Andy's question? Did she take the high road or did it just make her look guilty? Weigh in below!

Source: People, Watch What Happens Live