Season 1 Episode 17

Title: Truth Be Told
Air Date: March 10, 2010 at 9:00 PM PST

Phil (Ty Burrell) reconnects with an old high school girlfriend through Facebook and invites her over to the house, but things don't go as expected. Jay (Ed O’Neill) stops at nothing to cover up his tracks when he accidentally kills Manny’s (Rico Rodriguez) pet turtle, and Mitchell (Jesse Tyler Ferguson), who feels extremely overworked, finally confronts his boss.