When we first started to speculate that Naya Rivera had called off her engagement to rapper Big Sean, we didn’t want to believe it. The Glee star seemed happier than ever in recent months, even gushing that her fiance was going to make “an amazing husband” and someday “a great father.”

Sadly, it seems there was trouble in paradise that none of us could have expected. On Wednesday, April 9, the couple shocked all of us by suddenly announcing that they had decided to break up.

“After careful thought and consideration, Sean has made the difficult decision to call the wedding off,” revealed a rep for the rapper. “Sean wishes Naya nothing but the best and it is still his hope that they can continue to work through their issues privately.” The statement came on the heels of rumors that Sean had cheated on Naya and even stole Rolex watches from a woman’s house.

We can’t imagine what Naya must be feeling right now, but she’s certainly putting on a brave face. Just one day before the announcement, the 27-year-old actress attended the Marie Claire Fresh Faces Party at the Soho House in West Hollywood. As usual, Naya flaunted her killer figure in a belly-baring outfit by Philosophy, which she paired with a bright, happy smile and a ringless finger.

Are you sad to hear about the end of Naya’s engagement? Do you think the couple can work it out? Let us know your thoughts in the comments below!