Who Wore It Best Wednesdays: Michelle Trachtenberg vs. Emma Roberts in Alice + Olivia

If there’s one thing Gossip Girl guest star Michelle Trachtenberg knows how to do, it’s wear the hell out of a dress on the red carpet. The fashionista’s known for choosing form-fitting frocks that accentuate her curves — and this time was no different! At the launch of the Missoni for Target Collection on September 7, 2011, Michelle stepped out in a $330 navy Alice + Olivia “Goddess” dress with ruched silk-chiffon panels. Pumping up the glam of the long-sleeved jersey minidress, M added art deco earrings, a metallic clutch, and eye-catching gold Brian Atwood platform pumps.

But what’s this? Are we seeing double? Emma Roberts wore the exactly same A+O dress (but in black) at a VMA after-party just a week prior, on August 28. The Scream 4 actress kept the look more edgy than elegant with Fendi cut-out booties, shocking red lips, and an Anya Hindmarch glitter clutch to add a touch of allure to her otherwise understated look.

Personally, we’re feeling Emma’s modern take on the look, but who are we to judge? That’s your job, fashionistas! Who wore it best?