On Life Unexpected, Kristoffer Polaha played Britt Robertson’s father, Nathaniel “Baze” Bazile. He too quickly recast after The CW decided not to renew the series. Then they made a home for him as Henry Butler, one of Sarah Michelle Geller’s many love interests on Ringer. But then that show got cancelled. Now the dude's got himself another gig — on CBS's upcoming legal drama Made in Jersey. Third time's a charm?