THEN: Stephen Colletti, Seasons 1-2
Stephen was the loveable player who toyed with LC and Kristin’s hearts all throughout Laguna Beach Seasons 1 and 2. Though he was definitely to blame for the added drama, he was just too cute to criticize!
Clearly he made the wrong decision when he sided with Kristin, but true love knows no bounds. Stephen and Kristin just wanted to live in a world where he “wouldn’t hook up with any girls” and she “wouldn’t hook up with any guys” — a world that couldn’t actually exist.