It’s Once Upon a Time’s Colin O’Donoghue (Captain Hook) by a Landslide!
Once Upon a Time newbie Colin O’Donoghue, who positively smolders as rakishly handsome Captain Hook, has this one in the bag with 38.16% of the votes. Coming in second with a respectable 24.65% is Glee’s Dean Geyer (Brody) — he of the sexy shirtless bod.
The poll is still open, so if your favorite new guy is trailing, make sure to vote him to the top!
Rounding out the poll’s eight-pack of hotties are Nashville’s Sam Palladio (Gunnar), Glee’s Jacob Artist (Jake), The Vampire Diaries’ David Alpay (Professor Shane), Arrow’s Stephen Amell (Oliver), Revenge’s Barry Sloane (Aiden Mathis), and Bones’ Luke Kleintank (Finn).