Credit: Brad Barket/Getty Images Photo: Aubrey O'Day

We're so used to seeing Aubrey O'Day with doll-like eye makeup, it's hard to believe this parrot photo shows the same person!

Danity Kane singer and Celebrity Apprentice alum Aubrey, 29, was recently in Hawaii with her boyfriend when they were surrounded by gorgeous birds. 

Credit: Instagram Photo: Aubrey O'Day in Maui

She shared the photo at left on Instagram, writing, "screw redbull, Maui gives u wings!"

The parrots — and her handsome man — are impressive enough, but we can't stop marveling at how different she looks when going “natural.” Us Weekly has another less flattering shot of makeup-free Aubrey carrying coffee and wearing one of her trademark revealing outfits.

What do you think: Does Aubrey look better fresh-faced or with the makeup?

Sources: InstagramUs Weekly, Perez Hilton