Credit: ABC

Credit: Kevin Winter/Getty Images Photo: It's Eric Stonestreet From Modern Family

One Modern Family actor's TV career hasn't always been a laughing matter! This funnyman has had bloody roles in two shows spearheaded by Ryan Murphy: Nip/Tuck and American Horror Story. But which dude are we talkin' 'bout here?

That's the quiz we gave Viggle LIVE! users — and 49 percent of you got the answer right! It's Eric Stonestreet — aka Modern Family's Cam.

For the record, 33 percent thought it was Jesse Tyler Ferguson (Mitchell) and 18 thought it was Ed O'Neill (Jay).

In the Nip/Tuck Season 6 finale, "Wesley Clovis," Eric played a murderer-rapist too obese to execute by lethal injection (which is where the plastic surgeon protagonists come in).  

In the American Horror Story Season 1 episode "Piggy Piggy," he played a psychiatric patient terrified of the urban legend of the murderer in the mirror — who, through an ironic twist of fate, was shot dead by a home invader in his bathroom just as he was confronting his fear.

Do you want to test your TV and movie knowledge? It’s easy — and you even get to earn rewards for watching your favorite shows. All you have to do is download the Viggle App, get watching, and join in on the fun of Viggle LIVE!