Credit: VSummers / Splash News Photo: Anne Hathaway at the 2012 New York City Ballet Fall Gala on September 20, 2012

We’re usually big fans of actress Anne Hathaway and her fashion choices — she was in The Devil Wears Prada after all! — but the gown that the newly-engaged star chose to wear to the 2012 New York City Ballet Fall Gala at Lincoln Center in New York City on Sept. 20 had us asking all sorts of questions.

For starters, the floor-length floral Valentino frock overwhelmed Anne’s petite frame, and the high-neck just didn't read glamorous to us. Was she trying something new? Was she pushing her fashion limits? And what about the sheer, curtain-like fabric? Again, so many questions.

Still, we give her points for her daring dress and opting to still rock her super-short hair even after Les Miserables has wrapped.

What’s your take on Anne’s ballet ensemble? Vote below!