Credit: Frederick M. Brown/Getty Images; Jason Merritt/Getty Images Photo: Nicole Richie vs. Torrey DeVitto, Yellow Dress Edition

Summer may be gone, but our favorite fashionistas aren’t forgoing bright colors in favor of boring shades. On October 15, 2011, Nicole Richie stepped out for the 21st Annual Environmental Media Awards in a lemon-hued Keepsake “Lost Without You” dress. The $145 frock boasted a ruffled neckline and cut-out details at the waist, looking ultra sweet and girlie on the typically boho-clad star. Christian Louboutin “Luxura” pumps and a studded House of Harlow clutch were the perfect accessories, providing a needed dose of edge.

Pretty Little Liars star Torrey DeVitto took a cue from Ms. Richie, rocking a similarly colored frock to the 2011 Spike TV Scream Awards on the very same night. T paired her ¾-length sleeve H&M dress with black tights, a black clutch, and simple patent pumps for an easy yet adorable red carpet look.

While Torrey’s look is undoubtedly cute, we can’t deny that Nicole’s outfit is bursting with personality. So now that you know our vote, what’s yours? Who wore it best?