Credit: The CW; ABC; MTV; HBO; The CW; HBO

We can go back and forth over which supernatural show has the hottest cast till the werewolves come home (seriously, don’t get us started), so now that you fans have settled on Supernatural, let’s debate something new: Which supernatural show has the best writing? Sure, it’s not as sexy, but with all those snarky vamps out there, it’s actually a pretty tough call.

While we’re torn between True Blood and The Vampire Diaries, there’s a helluva lot to be said for their competition.

Just like a spell, cast your vote in the poll below!